Sharh Fiqh as-Sunnah Kitâb at-Tahârah #35
Rulings Related to
Recommended at the following times:
With the Salât
Before reciting the
When rising from
When the taste in
one’s mouth has changed.
The ruling of the Siwâk before the Salât
Is it Wâjib and the Salât is
invalid without it (As is attributed to Is’hâq Ibn Râhûyah)?
Or is it Wâjib, but the Salât is
not invalidated without it (As is the opinion of Dâwûd Ibn ‘Alî)?
Or is it Mustahabb (As
is the opinion of the majority)?
The Ruling regarding the one fasting
Is it disliked after the Zawâl (As
is the famous opinion of the Shâfi’iyyah and Hanâbilah)?
Or is it disliked with something moist at all
times, and not disliked with something dry, at all times (As
is the opnion of Mâlik and a narration from Ahmad)?
Or is it not disliked; before or after Zawâl
(As is the opinion of the Ahnâf)?
Siwâk in the Masjid
Is it disliked (As is the opinion
of some of the Ahnâf, and it is the Mâlikî Math’hab)?
Or is it recommended, as in all places
(As is the opinion of the majority)?
Using the Siwâk in the presence of people
It is disliked (As is the opinion
of some of the Mâlikiyyah)?
That it is not disliked
(As is the opinion of the rest)?